Loading…
Premier League
Manchester United have managed just one win from five Premier League matches under Michael Carrick, with Phil Bardsley slamming Bruno Fernandes' form and the defence's collapse. Kieran McKenna waits in the wings as pressure mounts at Old Trafford.
Let's not sugarcoat it. Manchester United have been dreadful. One win from five Premier League matches is not a slow start; it is a crisis in the making. Under Michael Carrick, the club that fancies itself among England's elite has looked listless, disorganised, and utterly devoid of the intensity required at this level. Defeats to Hull City and Manchester City, paired with limp draws against Everton and Fulham, paint a picture that should have every United fan reaching for the panic button.
Five points from five games. According to 90min, the last time Manchester United opened a season this poorly, the consequences were severe. History is not kind to managers who stumble out of the gate at Old Trafford, and Carrick is running out of runway fast.
Former Manchester United defender Phil Bardsley did not hold back when assessing Bruno Fernandes this season, and frankly, it is hard to argue with him. Yes, Fernandes has three goals and an assist to his name. On paper, those are decent numbers. In reality, every single one of those contributions came in the sole victory against Ipswich Town. Strip out that one afternoon, and the captain has been a ghost.
Bardsley described Fernandes as "unusually flat," which feels generous. This is a player who has carried United on his back in previous campaigns, dragging the squad through difficult spells with sheer force of will. That player is nowhere to be seen right now. When your captain and creative heartbeat goes missing, it infects the entire squad. United's struggles are not all on Fernandes, but his inability to influence matches beyond Ipswich is a glaring red flag for Carrick and for anyone backing United in the betting markets.
If Fernandes' form is a concern, the backline is a full-blown emergency. Bardsley was damning in his assessment, pointing to a total lack of energy and fitness during the loss to Hull City. Alarming is the word he used, and it fits. Late goals conceded against Brighton and Everton suggest a team that cannot concentrate for 90 minutes, a group that switches off precisely when it matters most.
There is no collective identity in defence. No aggression. No accountability. Carrick's players look like individuals sharing a pitch rather than a unit defending together. For a manager whose playing career was built on discipline and positional intelligence, the irony is painful. The man who once shielded United's defence with metronomic composure now presides over a backline that crumbles under the slightest pressure.
When a Manchester United manager wobbles, the vultures circle. And right now, one name keeps surfacing: Kieran McKenna. The former United coach, who guided Ipswich Town from League One all the way to the Premier League before departing, is available and reportedly open to discussions with the club. As Goal reported, McKenna is seen as a "ready replacement" should the axe fall on Carrick.
McKenna's credentials are real. Back-to-back promotions with Ipswich demonstrated tactical acumen and an ability to build a winning culture from scratch. His familiarity with Old Trafford, having worked within United's coaching setup, removes the usual adjustment period that outside appointments require. He knows the building. He knows the expectations. And crucially, he knows how to get a group of players pulling in the same direction, something Carrick has conspicuously failed to achieve.
Michael Carrick is not yet a dead man walking, but he is close. The fixture list will not wait for him to find answers. The defensive fragility, Fernandes' disappearing act, and the general lack of cohesion all point to deeper structural issues that a couple of training-ground tweaks will not fix.
If results do not improve quickly, the pressure to make a change will become irresistible. The Manchester United board has never been known for patience, and five points from five matches is the kind of return that accelerates difficult conversations. Whether Carrick can turn this around or whether Kieran McKenna gets the call, the next few weeks will tell us everything about where this season is heading for the Red Devils.
Jon
